Single-leg vs. Squats Pros and Cons


Nov 28, 2021

 by chris windbigler
Share

Single-Leg Squats vs. Bilateral Squats: Which One is Right for You?

Introduction:

Squats are an excellent exercise for working your lower body and core, but they're not the only way. Single leg exercises such as lunges, step-ups, and single-leg squats target some of the same muscle groups while also helping to improve balance. A common misconception is that single-leg exercises will give you "weaker" legs than squats do, but this isn't true! With regular practice, both types of exercises can be equally beneficial. Which would be better for you? Read on and find out!

Single-Leg Squats: Benefits and Muscles Worked

Single-leg squats, also known as pistol squats, are a challenging exercise that necessitates balance and coordination, which engages all of the muscle groups worked by traditional squats, but with less pressure on your spine, adding to its benefits. The muscles worked by single-leg squats include quads, hamstrings, glutes, core muscles, hips, and the biceps femoris muscle in the back of your thigh.

According to a study by IJSPT, it is beneficial to perform unilateral rather than bilateral squats for people with low back pain and those participating in rehab programs after ACL ruptures. Unilateral squats are performed with smaller loads (61.7 lbs vs. 297 lbs) but attain roughly the same level of muscle activity in the hamstring, calf, hip, and abdominal muscles while putting less strain on the spine.

The benefits of single-leg squats include being easier on the joints because you only have one weight-bearing joint per leg. This means you can do more reps and sets with less risk for injury. You also get a better core workout than regular squats because it requires more stabilization from your abdomen and lower back muscles. However, when you do single-leg squats and other similar movements with only one foot on the ground, it creates an unequal load between both sides of the body by placing more weight on one side than the other. When this happens over time, it can cause weak muscles, imbalances, and movement patterns that may lead to injury if not corrected properly.

Bilateral Squats: Benefits and Drawbacks

On the other hand, if your goal is building strength, then regular squatting could be better for you since it involves doing heavy loads with both legs at once. Regular squats force your body to work harder against gravity and build muscle mass by lifting heavier weights over time. Moreover, studies have proven it to be one of the best exercises for building thigh muscle and reducing body fat around that area. In terms of biomechanics, squats work both large and small muscles in your legs, providing an efficient workout while still low impact.

However, there are some disadvantages of squats that you should know about before starting this workout routine. For example, if you have knee problems or any other joint issues, squats may not be appropriate for you because they put pressure on these areas, leading to injury. Squats are also associated with back pain from incorrect form or lack of warm-up before starting, which also causes soreness or strain.

How to do One-Legged Squats (Pistol Squats)

  1. Stand on one leg with the other leg extended straight in front of you.
  2. Slowly lower yourself down into a squat position, keeping your chest up and core engaged.
  3. Go as low as you can while maintaining balance and good form.
  4. Push through the heel of your standing leg to return to the starting position.
  5. Repeat on the other side.

Conclusion:

The difference between single-leg and bilateral squats is not tricky but focuses on a particular muscle group. There's no correct answer when choosing